Erosion of Local News Weakening Community Bonds and Civic Understanding Across Canada
A comprehensive new report from the Public Policy Forum think-tank reveals a deepening crisis in local journalism across Canada, with severe consequences for small towns and communities. "The Lost Estate: How to put the local back in local news," paints a stark picture of dwindling local news outlets and their impact on civic engagement, community cohesion, and understanding of local governance. The report, conducted in partnership with the Rideau Hall Foundation and the Michener Awards Foundation, underscores the critical role of local news in a healthy democracy and calls for immediate action to revitalize this vital sector.
The study’s findings, based on an Ipsos poll of over 1,000 Canadians residing in communities with populations under 100,000, highlight a growing awareness of the problem. An overwhelming 87% of respondents emphasized the importance of local news for a functioning democracy. Moreover, a significant majority – 61% – acknowledged the direct link between declining local news coverage and diminished knowledge about crucial local institutions such as municipal governments, schools, and hospitals. Equally concerning, 58% of respondents agreed that the erosion of local news contributes to a weakening of community ties and social fabric.
The report’s authors, including veteran journalists Andrew Phillips, Edward Greenspon, and Alison Uncles, identify a confluence of factors contributing to the decline of local news. Shrinking advertising revenues, coupled with the transition to digital platforms where local outlets struggle to compete with larger national and international media, have severely impacted the financial viability of local news organizations. The dominance of corporate ownership models, often prioritizing profit over community service, has further exacerbated the situation. Research from Toronto Metropolitan University confirms this trend, documenting the closure of 252 local news outlets since 2008, with a further 24 closures in the last two years alone.
However, amidst this bleak landscape, the report identifies glimmers of hope and potential solutions. A "flourishing new ecosystem" of digital startups, exemplified by Village Media’s success in Ontario, demonstrates the potential for innovative, community-focused online models to fill the void left by traditional media. The report stresses the need for diversified funding sources to support these emerging models and bolster existing local news organizations. Recommendations include tax incentives for local businesses to advertise in local media, increased philanthropic support from foundations and individual donors, and a re-evaluation of government funding models.
Specifically, the report proposes the establishment of a non-profit organization to fund reporters in local newsrooms for three-year terms, providing much-needed stability and resources. It also advocates for expanding the Local Journalism Initiative, currently supported by federal funds, through philanthropic donations and independent governance. Furthermore, the report suggests directing a portion of government advertising budgets towards local media, recognizing its crucial role in disseminating public information and fostering civic engagement. Finally, encouraging community and private foundations to support local news aligns with their broader missions of promoting community health and strengthening democratic institutions.
The consequences of inaction are dire. The report warns that the vacuum created by the decline of local news is often filled by national media, characterized by a more divisive and partisan tone, and by social media platforms, where misinformation and disinformation proliferate. This contributes to a growing cynicism towards news in general, further eroding public trust in institutions and exacerbating social divisions. Andrew Phillips, a co-author of the report, emphasizes the crucial role of local news in countering this trend. "More local news is a little bit of an antidote to that," he states, highlighting the importance of providing accurate, context-specific information that fosters informed civic participation and strengthens community bonds.
The report concludes with a call to action, urging a collaborative effort involving readers, local businesses, philanthropic organizations, and government to preserve and revitalize local journalism. "People have to step in and do this, and obviously readers have to play their part by consuming it and in one way or another, paying for it," Phillips asserts. The future of local news, and indeed the health of local communities and democracy itself, hinges on the collective willingness to invest in and support this essential pillar of civic life. The report’s findings, coupled with the alarming statistics on news outlet closures, serve as a stark reminder of the urgency of this challenge and the need for immediate, concerted action. The time to invest in the future of local news is now.