Nuns Fight Disinformation, Earn National Award
The 2024 presidential election cycle, fraught with tension and accusations of voter fraud, saw the Benedictine Sisters of Erie, Pennsylvania, become unexpected targets of a viral disinformation campaign. Republican activist Cliff Maloney, in an attempt to rally GOP voters, falsely claimed on X (formerly Twitter) that 53 voters were registered to the nuns’ address, despite no residents living there. Maloney’s post quickly gained traction, fueling the narrative of widespread voter fraud and accusing the sisters of being complicit in a Democratic scheme to manipulate election results.
The sisters swiftly and decisively refuted Maloney’s allegations. In a public statement, Sister Stephanie Schmidt, then-prioress of the monastery, clarified that the nuns resided at Mount Saint Benedict Monastery and were active members of the Erie community. She pointed out that a simple online search would have confirmed their presence and condemned Maloney’s post as “blatantly false.” The nuns’ response highlighted the importance of fact-checking and the dangers of spreading misinformation, particularly during a critical election period.
The Benedictine Sisters’ courageous stand against disinformation earned them the prestigious 2025 Margaret Chase Smith American Democracy Award from the National Association of Secretaries of State (NASS). This award recognizes individuals who demonstrate political courage, exceptional character, and selfless public service. Pennsylvania’s Secretary of the Commonwealth, Al Schmidt (no relation to Sister Stephanie Schmidt), nominated the sisters for the award, praising their thoughtful response and their call for a discerning and conscientious citizenry.
Sister Linda Romey, director of communications for the monastery, shared the nuns’ experience in an interview with Votebeat and Spotlight PA. She recounted the initial shock and the outpouring of support they received from across the country. The sisters, well-known for their community involvement, were immediately defended by local officials, political figures, and the broader Erie community. Romey also noted the monastery’s open invitation to Maloney to visit and learn firsthand about their community, an invitation that remains open.
The incident involving the Benedictine Sisters underscores the vulnerability of individuals and communities to disinformation campaigns, especially during politically charged times. The sisters’ story serves as a powerful example of the importance of challenging false narratives and promoting media literacy. Their decision to speak out not only protected their reputation but also served as a crucial reminder of the need for careful scrutiny of information circulating online.
The award bestowed upon the Benedictine Sisters serves as a poignant reminder of the power of truth and the importance of civic engagement in combating disinformation. Their experience highlights the essential role of individuals, communities, and organizations in defending democratic principles and promoting responsible information consumption. The sisters’ legacy extends beyond their immediate community, serving as an inspiration for others to challenge falsehoods and uphold the integrity of democratic processes.