UN Expert Calls for Urgent Fossil Fuel Phase-Out, Citing Human Rights Violations and Industry Obstruction
GENEVA – A United Nations human rights expert has issued a stark warning to the global community, calling for an immediate and decisive shift away from fossil fuels. In a comprehensive report presented to the UN Human Rights Council, Elisa Morgera, the UN Special Rapporteur on human rights and climate change, highlighted the devastating impact of the fossil fuel industry on human rights and the environment, emphasizing the urgency of a “defossilization” of the global economy within the current decade. Morgera’s report, which underscores the industry’s decades-long campaign of climate obstruction, goes beyond simply advocating for a transition to renewable energy. It calls for a series of radical measures, including a ban on fossil fuel advertising and lobbying, the criminalization of industry misinformation and “greenwashing,” and legal protections for environmental human rights defenders.
Morgera’s report paints a grim picture of the widespread consequences of fossil fuel use, linking it directly to climate change, biodiversity loss, and a litany of human rights violations. She emphasizes the overwhelming scientific consensus on the role of fossil fuels in driving climate change, arguing that continued reliance on these fuels is incompatible with a sustainable future. The report stresses the inadequacy of current climate mitigation efforts, noting that they fall far short of the greenhouse gas reductions needed to limit global warming to 1.5°C, a target widely considered crucial for averting catastrophic climate impacts. Despite this dire assessment, Morgera maintains that achieving a “liveable and sustainable future” remains possible, provided the international community takes decisive action within the next decade.
Central to Morgera’s argument is the concept of a “just transition” away from fossil fuels. This transition, she argues, must be grounded in human rights principles and prioritize the needs of communities most affected by the climate crisis and the shift away from fossil fuels. This includes not only financial support for affected workers and communities but also a fundamental shift in power dynamics, ensuring that affected communities have a genuine voice in shaping the transition process. The report also underscores the importance of addressing “historical responsibilities and current injustices,” calling for remedies for the harms caused by fossil fuel activities to be developed in collaboration with impacted communities.
Morgera’s report goes beyond simply advocating for the cessation of fossil fuel use. She advocates for a comprehensive dismantling of the industry’s influence, arguing that the fossil fuel industry’s efforts to obstruct climate action and mislead the public represent a grave threat to human rights. The report calls on governments to implement a range of measures to counter this influence, including banning fossil fuel advertising and promotions, prohibiting lobbying by the industry, and criminalizing the spread of misinformation about climate change and the role of fossil fuels. This call for criminalization extends to “greenwashing,” a practice where companies falsely portray their products or operations as environmentally friendly. Furthermore, Morgera urges states to provide robust legal protections for environmental human rights defenders who often face harassment, intimidation, and even violence for their work exposing the industry’s harmful practices.
The report explicitly links the right to life with the phase-out of fossil fuels. Morgera argues that states have a duty to protect their citizens from the devastating consequences of climate change, a duty that necessitates a rapid transition away from fossil fuels. To operationalize this duty, she recommends a series of concrete steps, including prohibiting new licenses for fossil fuel operations and revoking existing ones. This bold recommendation underscores the urgency of the situation and the need for immediate and decisive action.
The report’s recommendations are likely to face significant resistance, particularly from the powerful fossil fuel industry and governments with close ties to it. Some critics have already dismissed the report as “radical and untenable,” highlighting the potential for a fierce political battle over its implementation. However, Morgera maintains that the transition to renewable energy is not only essential for protecting human rights and the environment but also economically advantageous. She points to the decreasing costs and increasing reliability of renewable energy technologies, arguing that the transition is not only feasible but also represents a sound economic investment. The report underscores that transitioning away from fossil fuels is not simply an environmental imperative but a matter of fundamental human rights, a necessary step to secure a just and sustainable future for all.