Rian Johnson’s “Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery” Delves into Darker Territory at TIFF Premiere
Rian Johnson’s highly anticipated third installment in the Knives Out series, “Wake Up Dead Man,” made its world premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival, marking a darker turn for the popular whodunit franchise. While retaining the witty banter and intricate plotting of its predecessors, this latest entry embraces a gothic, Edgar Allan Poe-esque atmosphere, as hinted by the title itself. The film, clocking in at just over two hours and twenty-one minutes, maintains a brisk pace as it navigates a complex murder mystery set within the confines of a small-town church.
The film opens with the introduction of Josh O’Connor as Jud Duplenticy, a young priest grappling with the aftermath of the “Good Friday Murder” within his own congregation. Through Jud’s narration, delivered as a letter to an undisclosed recipient, the audience is introduced to the eccentric cast of characters who become potential suspects. This initial setup allows for audience speculation and clue-gathering before the eventual arrival of Benoit Blanc, played once again by Daniel Craig. O’Connor’s performance stands out, balancing dark humor with a palpable sense of desperation as his character becomes increasingly entangled in the unfolding mystery.
Upon Benoit Blanc’s arrival at the Chimney Rock, New York church, the investigation kicks into high gear. The church, led by the charismatic Monsignor Jefferson Wicks (Josh Brolin), harbors a close-knit community with a shared sense of grievance and a susceptibility to Wicks’ fiery rhetoric. The congregation includes Martha (Glenn Close), Samson (Thomas Haden Church), Vera (Kerry Washington), Cy (Daryl McCormack), Lee (Andrew Scott), Nat (Jeremy Renner), and Simone (Cailee Spaeny), each harboring secrets and potential motives. Johnson’s masterful casting shines through as this ensemble cast brings a unique dynamic to the narrative.
As the story progresses, the unsettling nature of Wicks’ preaching becomes apparent. Exploiting the anxieties and frustrations of his followers, he cultivates a culture of fear, suspicion, and disdain for outsiders. This theme resonates with contemporary anxieties surrounding disinformation, echo chambers, and the manipulation of belief systems. While the film draws parallels with current social and political climates, it never loses sight of its core focus: the power of storytelling, the nature of truth, and the deceptive facades people construct.
The central conflict in “Wake Up Dead Man” revolves around the clash between Benoit Blanc’s rational approach to detective work and the seemingly unshakeable faith of Wicks’ followers. How does one challenge deeply ingrained beliefs and expose the manipulations at play? Johnson deftly navigates this complex terrain, weaving together twists, turns, and revelations that keep the audience guessing until the very end. The gothic setting, complete with grand churches and hidden crypts, adds a layer of intrigue and suspense to the proceedings.
While “Wake Up Dead Man” touches on timely themes, it ultimately remains rooted in the classic tropes of the mystery genre. The film explores the human tendency to believe the unbelievable, to seek connections where none exist, and to construct narratives that serve personal agendas. It’s a testament to Johnson’s skill as a filmmaker that he’s able to blend these elements seamlessly, creating a captivating and thought-provoking cinematic experience. The film’s ending effectively ties together loose ends while leaving the audience pondering the larger questions raised throughout the story. With its clever plot, stellar performances, and timely resonance, “Wake Up Dead Man” proves that Rian Johnson’s Knives Out universe continues to offer fresh perspectives on the beloved mystery genre. Receiving a B+ grade from IndieWire, the film promises to be another engaging and entertaining addition to the franchise.