Vatican Conclave Beset by Disinformation Campaign as Cardinals Convene to Elect New Pope
The Vatican City is bracing for the commencement of a highly secretive conclave on Wednesday, tasked with electing a successor to Pope Francis. However, the solemn occasion has been marred by a deluge of disinformation circulating online, sowing confusion and casting a shadow over the proceedings. This mirrors the late Pope Francis’s own papacy, which was frequently targeted by false narratives, leading him to condemn disinformation as a "tragedy" that fuels conflict. The conclave, a closed-door event held within the Sistine Chapel, will see 133 Cardinal electors sequestered until a two-thirds majority elects the next pontiff. While recent conclaves have concluded within three days, the process can extend indefinitely until a consensus is reached. The Cardinals are bound by an oath of secrecy, but the sanctity of the process has been undermined by a surge of fabricated claims and conspiracy theories online.
Several instances of false information have surfaced, including unfounded assertions that the next pope has already been chosen. One such claim, circulating on YouTube, purported that Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle of the Philippines had been elected. This fabricated report was debunked by Filipino news outlets, and while Cardinal Tagle is considered a leading contender due to his moderate stance and focus on social justice, echoing the values of Pope Francis, the claim of his election prior to the conclave is categorically false. Similar misinformation targeting Cardinal Robert Sarah, favored by conservative factions within the Church, has also proliferated on social media platforms like Facebook and TikTok. These claims often feature AI-generated images, easily identifiable as manipulated, falsely depicting Cardinal Sarah in papal attire. There is no credible evidence to support these preemptive declarations of a papal election. The Holy See remains vacant, a period termed Sede Vacante, until the conclave concludes.
Adding to the disinformation campaign are false reports regarding the health of another prominent papal candidate, Cardinal Pietro Parolin of Italy. These rumors, attributed to various sources including some Italian news outlets and a US-based Catholic news website, alleged a decline in Cardinal Parolin’s health, potentially impacting his candidacy. However, the Holy See Press Office has unequivocally denied these claims, confirming that Cardinal Parolin has experienced no such health issues and refuting the need for any medical intervention. This type of misinformation, aimed at discrediting potential candidates, is not unprecedented, with similar tactics employed against Pope Francis prior to the 2013 conclave. Cardinal Parolin, a former chief advisor to Pope Francis, remains a strong contender for the papacy.
Beyond targeting specific individuals, the disinformation campaign has also extended to reputable media organizations. A fabricated screenshot mimicking an opinion piece from The Guardian newspaper, falsely attributed to journalist Yasmin Alibhai-Brown, has been circulated online. This forged article proposes that the next pope must be Muslim to prevent violence in Europe. Both The Guardian and Alibhai-Brown have confirmed the article’s inauthenticity. Alibhai-Brown hasn’t contributed to the publication since 2016, and closer inspection reveals the screenshot to be a manipulation, featuring a distorted version of The Guardian’s logo. This fabrication originated from a social media account notorious for attributing false headlines to the newspaper.
This wave of disinformation surrounding the papal conclave comes as no surprise, considering the increasing prevalence of fabricated content online and the heightened stakes associated with such a significant event. False information can easily spread through social media and online platforms, often amplified by algorithms and shared by unsuspecting users. The anonymity offered by the internet allows malicious actors to disseminate misinformation with little accountability. This phenomenon underscores the urgent need for critical media literacy and robust fact-checking mechanisms to counter the spread of false narratives. The disinformation targeting the conclave not only undermines the integrity of the process but also erodes trust in institutions and contributes to a climate of uncertainty and suspicion.
The challenges posed by online disinformation highlight the importance of relying on credible news sources and verifying information before sharing it. In the context of the papal conclave, the official communications from the Holy See Press Office should be considered the primary source of accurate information. The media, both traditional and online, have a crucial role to play in fact-checking and debunking false claims, ensuring that public discourse is informed by verified information rather than misleading narratives. As the conclave progresses, it is essential for individuals to exercise caution and discernment when encountering information related to the event, seeking out reliable sources and avoiding the spread of unsubstantiated claims. The election of the next pope is a momentous event for the Catholic Church and the world, and it is imperative that the process is not overshadowed by the disruptive influence of disinformation.