Harrison Considers Leaving School District Amidst Misinformation and Funding Concerns
The Harrison Select Board recently reignited discussions about the town’s future within Maine School Administrative District 17 (SAD 17), amidst a backdrop of misinformation and concerns over educational funding. Chairperson Matt Frank presented inaccuracies regarding SAD 17’s plans, claiming the district intends to close seven of eight elementary schools and build a new centralized school in the Norway/South Paris area. This claim is unequivocally false. SAD 17 is currently pursuing a plan known as Option 4C, which involves redistributing West Paris students to Paris Elementary School and constructing a new centralized school for students from Harrison, Waterford, and Norway. This would result in the closure of only three elementary schools, not seven. The remaining four elementary schools in Paris, Oxford, Hebron, and Otisfield would remain operational. This misinformation has fueled anxieties amongst residents regarding the future of education in Harrison.
Frank further compounded the confusion by misrepresenting the legal actions taken by West Paris and Paris. He suggested both towns were suing SAD 17 over the closure of seven schools. In reality, the legal action pertains specifically to the procedural handling of the Agnes Gray Elementary School closure in West Paris last February. Paris has since indicated its intention to withdraw its legal complaint. This mischaracterization of events adds another layer of complexity to an already sensitive issue.
The Select Board’s deliberations also centered on the condition of Harrison Elementary School (HES), citing a D-plus rating primarily due to the lack of a fire sprinkler system. Frank implied inaction on the part of the district regarding necessary improvements, including a new gymnasium floor. However, Superintendent Heather Manchester clarified that gym floor replacements are handled through a separate state loan program and that bids for the project were not received. Moreover, installing a sprinkler system at HES would require a capital improvement project and a district-wide referendum. SAD 17 is currently engaged in a $22 million capital improvement plan to address deferred maintenance across all elementary schools, and this cost could be significantly reduced if the partial consolidation plan (Option 4C) is approved.
A key driver in Harrison’s potential withdrawal from SAD 17 is the town’s disproportionately high contribution to the district’s budget, approximately 18%, while representing only about 6% of the student population. Frank contrasted Harrison with Oxford, suggesting the latter enjoys a more favorable financial position due to the presence of a casino, hotels, and a Walmart. However, Oxford Town Manager Adam Garland countered this assertion, emphasizing Oxford’s fiscal responsibility and the reinvestment of Tax Increment Financing (TIF) funds into public infrastructure. Crucially, the formula for determining local contributions to education is set at the state level and is beyond the control of any school district. Harrison’s higher assessment is linked to factors such as waterfront property values, which would continue to influence its educational costs regardless of its district affiliation.
The potential implications of Harrison leaving SAD 17 remain unclear. Frank indicated preliminary discussions with other area schools regarding student placement, but the financial ramifications are still being investigated. He suggested that alternative arrangements might be less costly than the current setup but offered no guarantees, even drawing comparisons to the high per-pupil expenditures of affluent communities like Cape Elizabeth. This uncertainty adds to the complexity of the situation.
To address these complex issues, a working group was established last spring to research the options and consequences of Harrison leaving SAD 17. This group consists of Chairperson Frank, Selectperson Debra Kane, Town Manager Cass Newell, and other community members. Kane has proposed formalizing the working group into a dedicated committee focused on Harrison’s educational future. The Board is actively seeking additional volunteers, particularly parents with school-aged children. Furthermore, the town has struggled to maintain consistent representation on the SAD 17 school board, with one seat currently vacant and another held by an appointee. This lack of stable representation potentially hinders effective communication and advocacy for Harrison’s interests within the district. The next steps for Harrison involve further investigation, community engagement, and careful consideration of the long-term impact of any decision regarding its relationship with SAD 17. The dialogue highlights the challenges of balancing educational quality, fiscal responsibility, and community interests in a complex educational landscape.