The Persistent Threat of Disinformation: A 2024 Retrospective and the Urgent Need for Local Action
The World Economic Forum’s 2025 Global Risks Report has once again highlighted the pervasive threat of mis- and disinformation, ranking it as the top global risk in the immediate term. This alarming assessment comes on the heels of Meta’s decision to discontinue third-party fact-checking on its platforms, a move that could further exacerbate the spread of false information. This echoes the 2024 report’s similar warning, underscoring the persistent and escalating nature of this challenge. The insidious nature of disinformation, its ability to erode trust and sow discord, makes it a particularly potent threat in the interconnected world. The past year has provided a stark reminder of disinformation’s destructive potential, impacting communities worldwide and highlighting the vulnerability of cities to its manipulative reach.
2024 unfolded as a year riddled with disinformation campaigns targeting various aspects of urban life. From the outset, with the “global election year” looming, the World Economic Forum’s prediction of disinformation’s dominance proved prescient. Subsequent months witnessed a relentless barrage of false narratives, impacting public health responses, exploiting terrorist attacks, manipulating local elections, fueling social unrest, and undermining disaster relief efforts. Examples include the anti-vaccine misinformation campaign during a measles outbreak in Florida, the manipulated footage and false accusations following a terrorist attack in Moscow, and the deepfake recording of a school principal in Baltimore that exacerbated existing community tensions.
The digital age, with its rapid information dissemination and ease of manipulation, has provided fertile ground for disinformation to flourish. The creation and spread of deepfakes, exemplified by the incident in Bacchus Marsh, Australia, where pornographic deepfakes of young girls were circulated, demonstrate the potential for devastating personal and societal harm. Climate disinformation campaigns, such as those surrounding London’s Ultra-Low Emissions Zone, have become increasingly sophisticated, leveraging social media and online platforms to influence public opinion and policy decisions. Furthermore, the exploitation of tragic events, like the murder of children in Southport, England, to fuel anti-immigrant sentiment through disinformation highlights the dangerous potential for real-world consequences.
The incidents throughout 2024 underscore the diverse forms disinformation can take and the breadth of its impact. From undermining public health initiatives and manipulating political discourse to inciting violence and hindering disaster response, the consequences are far-reaching and potentially devastating. The case of postal workers in Wellington, New Zealand, refusing to deliver pamphlets containing anti-Muslim disinformation demonstrates the growing awareness of the potential for such material to incite violence and harm community relations. Similarly, the disinformation surrounding Hurricanes Helene and Milton in the US, which included claims of manufactured storms and withheld aid, hampered emergency response efforts and sowed further distrust in authorities.
Recognizing the urgent need to address this growing threat, collaborative efforts have emerged to equip cities with the tools and knowledge to combat disinformation. The University of Melbourne, in partnership with the German Marshall Fund of the United States, has developed a global playbook to guide city responses to disinformation. This resource, co-created with multi-sector experts, represents a significant step towards providing practical strategies and best practices for local authorities. Complementing this effort, the Hunt Lab for Security and Intelligence, the Melbourne Centre for Cities, and the Municipal Association of Victoria have developed a micro-credential program focused on recognizing and managing disinformation, further empowering individuals and communities to identify and counter false narratives.
The fight against disinformation requires a multi-pronged approach, involving collaboration between academia, government, civil society, and tech companies. The Disinformation in the City project, with its focus on local responses to disinformation challenges, highlights the critical role of cities as front-line defenders against this pervasive threat. The project’s continued expansion, with support from the Municipal Association of Victoria and the Institute for Infrastructure in Society at the Australian National University, underscores the growing recognition of the need for localized strategies to counter disinformation. As we move forward, it is essential to prioritize media literacy initiatives, strengthen fact-checking mechanisms, and promote critical thinking skills to empower individuals to discern between credible information and malicious falsehoods. The ongoing efforts to understand and combat disinformation at the local level offer a beacon of hope in the face of this persistent challenge.
