Police Watchdog Urges Forces to Combat Online Disinformation Following Southport Stabbings and Subsequent Riots
A new report by His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire and Rescue Services (HMICFRS) has strongly criticized police forces for their inadequate response to online disinformation following the Southport stabbings last summer. The report highlights how misleading social media posts concerning the attacker’s identity fueled widespread riots across the country. The watchdog emphasizes the urgent need for police forces, social media companies, and Ofcom to collaborate more effectively and act swiftly to counter false information during periods of unrest.
Sir Andy Cooke, head of HMICFRS, stressed that the rapid spread of misinformation and disinformation on social media significantly contributed to the escalating disorder. He pointed to the failure of social media platforms to remove misleading posts promptly, exacerbating the situation. The report, the second published by the watchdog on the policing response to the riots, reveals that police forces had not implemented recommendations from previous inspectorate reports in 2011 and 2021, concerning intelligence gathering related to potential disorder and the effective management of social media.
The HMICFRS report asserts that police forces must proactively counter false narratives with accurate information, adopting a more open approach with established media outlets to ensure the public receives verified information during major investigations. Sir Andy Cooke emphasized the critical need for police forces to recognize the speed at which online content spreads and to develop innovative strategies to counter misinformation before it goes viral, filling the information void that allows false narratives to flourish and jeopardize public safety.
The report highlights the disparity in resources among police forces, noting that some lack the necessary capacity to effectively address online content due to limited resources. This disparity creates vulnerabilities in combating disinformation, hindering efforts to maintain public order and safety. The report underscores the urgent need for investment in resources and training to equip police forces with the tools and expertise to counter online disinformation effectively.
However, Gavin Stephens, chairman of the National Police Chiefs’ Council, called for a "more balanced assessment" of the report’s findings. He argued that law enforcement should not be responsible for regulating online content, placing the onus on individuals posting information, platform providers, and regulatory bodies to ensure accuracy and prevent the spread of harmful content. This highlights the ongoing debate regarding the role of law enforcement in managing online information and the balance between freedom of speech and public safety.
The report includes a stark comment from a police force head of communications, who admitted the police service lacks a comprehensive strategy for managing misinformation and disinformation. Merseyside Police Chief Constable Serena Kennedy acknowledged the report’s focus on the dangers of online content and confirmed that misinformation regarding the Southport stabbing suspect circulated rapidly on social media. She emphasized the force’s efforts to provide accurate information and urge the public to avoid sharing potentially harmful disinformation. This highlights the challenges faced by police forces in countering rapidly spreading misinformation and the need for proactive communication strategies to maintain public trust and prevent further unrest. The incident serves as a stark reminder of the potential consequences of unchecked online disinformation in today’s digital age and the urgent need for a multi-faceted approach involving law enforcement, social media platforms, and the public to combat this growing threat.
