Indonesia Battles Disinformation and Hate Speech Targeting Rohingya Refugees
The UN has highlighted the alarming global rise of dangerous rhetoric targeting marginalized groups, including religious minorities, migrants, refugees, and political opponents. This hate speech, often amplified by social media, fuels discrimination and violence, creating an environment of fear and intolerance. Indonesia, a nation with a history of welcoming refugees, recently found itself grappling with this disturbing trend, facing a wave of online disinformation and hate speech aimed at Rohingya refugees seeking safety on its shores.
In late 2023, boats carrying Rohingya refugees, fleeing persecution and dire conditions in Bangladesh camps, began arriving in Indonesia. This influx, though relatively small in a country of over 270 million, became the target of a coordinated online hate campaign. False narratives spread rapidly through social media platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and X (formerly Twitter), portraying the refugees as a threat and manipulating public perception. These platforms, designed for connection and communication, were weaponized to sow discord and fear, inciting hostility towards the vulnerable Rohingya community. The campaign marked the first time the UNHCR had experienced such a targeted attack globally and the first time the UN in Indonesia had to combat this level of online hostility.
The UN team in Indonesia, led by Resident Coordinator Valerie Julliand, launched a multi-pronged response to counter the disinformation and hate speech. Working with UNHCR, IOM, and UNIC, the team engaged with social media companies, the Indonesian Ministry of Communication and Information, traditional media outlets, academia, and civil society organizations. Their strategy involved textual analysis of social media posts, revealing the organized nature of the campaign. This evidence was shared with social media platforms, leading to the removal of offensive content and fake accounts. The Ministry of Communication and Information also played a crucial role, publicly labeling many of the posts as "hoaxes," further discrediting the misinformation.
The UN’s efforts to debunk the false narratives extended beyond social media engagement. The team provided accurate information to traditional media, which conducted their own investigations, confirming the UN’s findings and exposing the source of the hate campaign. Simultaneously, the UN utilized its own social media channels to share stories of the Rohingya refugees, humanizing their plight and countering the dehumanizing rhetoric of the online hate campaign. They highlighted the refugees’ resilience, their hopes for a better future, and their shared humanity, presenting them as individuals with stories, families, and dreams, rather than a faceless threat.
The UN’s efforts to shift the narrative included showcasing the refugees’ talents and contributions. They profiled a refugee who had memorized the Quran, resonating with Indonesia’s Muslim-majority population, and another who was a skilled cartoonist. They amplified the voice of a mother of four, who simply sought a safe and hopeful future for her children. This multifaceted approach aimed to foster empathy and understanding, challenging the prejudiced views fueled by the disinformation campaign. The UN also supported academics and NGOs who organized events to promote solidarity with the refugees, emphasizing the importance of accurate information and compassionate responses to those seeking refuge.
Despite these efforts, the impact of the hate campaign remained significant. Mobs were organized, refugee boats were pushed back, and tragically, lives were lost, including a mother and child. The hostility experienced in Indonesia also reached the refugee camps in Bangladesh, discouraging further arrivals and extinguishing the hopes of many seeking refuge. While the UN and its partners successfully exposed the organized nature of the hate campaign and countered some of the misinformation, they acknowledge the lasting impact of the hatred and the ongoing challenges in fostering a welcoming environment.
The UN team in Indonesia continues its support for the Rohingya refugees, advocating for their protection and well-being. Their experience highlights the critical need for continued vigilance against disinformation and hate speech, particularly in the digital age. The fight for accurate information and compassionate narratives remains crucial in building a more inclusive and tolerant global community. The Indonesian case serves as a stark reminder of the devastating consequences of unchecked online hate speech and the urgent need for collective action to counter it.
