Canadian Media’s Anti-Israel Bias: A Case Study of The Catholic Register
Over the past 18 months, a concerning trend has emerged in Canadian news media: the persistent demonization of Israel. This bias ranges from ignoring Palestinian terrorism to uncritically echoing Hamas propaganda, effectively misinforming Canadians about the Middle East. Disturbingly, this phenomenon isn’t confined to mainstream outlets like The Toronto Star or CBC News but has seeped into religious publications as well. A prime example is The Catholic Register, which bills itself as "Canada’s leading source of Catholic news since 1893." An April 17 article by their Ottawa correspondent, Susan Korah, titled "Holy Land Easter under shadow of war," illustrates this concerning bias.
Korah’s article purports to depict the suffering of Holy Land Christians due to conflict, but quickly devolves into a platform for unsubstantiated anti-Israel accusations. The piece focuses solely on Israel’s alleged transgressions, completely omitting any mention of Hamas or Palestinian terrorism. One of Korah’s claims is that Christians are "not allowed" to visit Jerusalem, implying Israeli restrictions. This assertion is demonstrably false, as evidenced by the recent Palm Sunday procession in Jerusalem, where thousands of Christians participated without incident. Korah neglects to provide any evidence for her claim or specify who is supposedly preventing Christians from accessing the city.
Further fueling the misinformation, Korah quotes Joseph Hazboun, an employee of a local aid organization, who describes "emotionally exhausting times for Christians" due to "bloodshed and famine emerging daily from Gaza." While Hazboun’s concerns may be genuine, Korah fails in her journalistic duty to verify and contextualize these claims. The allegation of a "vicious starvation campaign" by Israel is patently false. Gaza receives substantial daily humanitarian aid, sufficient to feed its entire population, supplemented by locally produced food. Despite months of warnings about an impending famine by various aid organizations, no such crisis has materialized.
The core narrative of Korah’s article – that Jerusalem’s Christians are suffering solely due to Israel – is a gross misrepresentation. The reality, conveniently omitted by Korah, is that Israel is the only Middle Eastern country where the Christian population is consistently growing, increasing at approximately 1.3 percent annually. In contrast, Christian populations have plummeted in neighboring regions, including an 80 percent decline in Syria and a 70 percent decrease in Gaza over recent decades. This stark difference underscores a crucial fact: Israel, unlike Gaza or many other Middle Eastern nations, guarantees religious freedom to all its citizens.
The omission of this crucial context, combined with the uncritical acceptance of dubious claims, paints a distorted picture of the situation in the Holy Land. Korah’s article ignores the complexities on the ground, reducing the narrative to a simplistic "Israel bad, Palestinians good" trope that does a disservice to both truth and reconciliation. By selectively focusing on alleged Israeli wrongdoings and ignoring the role of Hamas and other Palestinian actors, Korah perpetuates a narrative that is not only inaccurate but also fuels anti-Israel sentiment. The lack of journalistic rigor in this piece is particularly concerning given the sensitive nature of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
The publication of such a biased and misleading article in The Catholic Register, a publication affiliated with a faith that originated with Jews in the Land of Israel, is particularly troubling. It represents a betrayal of the publication’s stated mission to provide accurate and balanced news. Moreover, it contributes to the broader problem of misinformation regarding Israel in Canadian media. This pattern of biased reporting not only undermines public understanding of the conflict but also fuels harmful stereotypes and contributes to a climate of hostility towards Israel.
This incident underscores the urgent need for greater media literacy and critical analysis of news reporting, especially when it comes to complex geopolitical issues like the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Readers should be encouraged to scrutinize the sources, evidence, and narratives presented in news articles and seek out diverse perspectives. The Catholic Register’s publication of this article serves as a cautionary tale about the insidious nature of bias in media and the importance of demanding accurate and balanced reporting, particularly from outlets that claim to uphold ethical journalistic standards.
